Dodgers Roundtable: Should An Outfielder Be Traded?
Dodgers Roundtable: Should An Outfielder Be Traded?
Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports

PAGES: 1 | 2

For much of the past three seasons the Los Angeles Dodgers have carried a surplus of outfielders on their active roster.

The position group’s depth grew a bit this offseason as the Dodgers’ three-team trade with the Cincinnati Reds and Chicago White Sox added Trayce Thompson to the organization.

Los Angeles also acquired second baseman Micah Johnson and right-hander Frankie Montas in the trade. Thompson made his Major League debut with the White Sox last season, appearing in 44 games.

The Dodgers currently have eight outfielders on their 40-man roster; the number includes super utility man Kiké Hernandez.

Recent reports have the White Sox kicking the tires on a potential trade for Andre Ethier. However, it’s believed Chicago first inquired on Yasiel Puig, who the Dodgers are not interested in trading.

While Ethier and perhaps to a lesser extent, Puig, are drawing interest, Los Angeles reportedly prefers to trade Carl Crawford.

Do the Dodgers need to trade an outfielder? Should they? The staff weighed in:

Matthew Moreno (@MMoreno1015)

While I do believe the Dodgers should trade an outfielder, I’m not sure if there’s a move to be made given the rumored candidates. Ideally, Crawford and/or Alex Guerrero would be shipped out.

I just don’t know if that’s feasible. Crawford’s age and contract make him difficult to move, while Guerrero comes with plenty of uncertainty and can opt out of his contract after the season in which he was traded.

He began last season well but cooled off, and his best “position” is designated hitter — assuming he can get squared away at the plate.

Barring a return that’s too good to turn down, trading Ethier would be a mistake. Yes, April 21 looms large as he’ll become a 10-and-5 player, but he presumably would waive the no-trade clause if playing time isn’t coming his way.

Trading Ethier at this juncture, specifically without yet seeing what Puig will provide, is too risky of a proposition for my liking. To sum it all up, I believe the Dodgers should break up the glut of outfielders if it means dealing Crawford or Guerrero.

Daniel Starkand (@DStarkand)

I think it would suit the Dodgers best to trade at least one, maybe even two outfielders. The two obvious names are Ethier and Crawford, but I would also include Guerrero in that category.

If they could trade any of them for a hard-throwing right-handed reliever, then I would not hesitate to pull the trigger. I would even include some money in the deal.

I believe Thompson is a Major-League ready prospect, and I would like to see him, along with Joc Pederson and Puig, if they are producing, as the team’s everyday outfielders by the trade deadline.

Matt Borelli (@MattDodgerBlue):

I don’t believe the Dodgers need to trade an outfielder. Having a plethora of depth is vital, especially if a player gets injured or struggles early in the season.

Additionally, the excess of depth gives new manager Dave Roberts a variety of options to choose from when constructing a lineup, where he can decide who to play based on the matchup or simply go with the hot bat.

If the front office believes a trade is necessary down the stretch, it makes more sense to entertain the idea closer the trade deadline where there will be more buyers, rather than selling low on a player in February.

CONTINUE READING: Making The Case To Trade An Outfielder