Dodgers Rumors: Verlander and Arenado to Los Angeles?
May 18, 2024; Houston, Texas, USA;Houston Astros starting pitcher Justin Verlander (35) pitches against the Milwaukee Brewers in the first inning at Minute Maid Park. Mandatory Credit: Thomas Shea-USA TODAY Sports

While there are still a couple of months until the trade deadline, the rumor mill has already been hard at work, specifically about what the Los Angeles Dodgers might have up their sleeves.

According to PromoGuy, the Dodgers remain the odds-on favorites to win the World Series at +350. Unlike last season, when they seemed content to sit back and see what happened in the playoffs, this team is in win-it-all-now mode, spending big in the offseason to sign Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinobu Yamamoto.

Can’t Have Too Much Depth

Few people doubt the mighty hitters within the Dodgers’ ranks. However, some players could be on their way out to make way for more positive additions. Offensive regression from James Outman and Chris Taylor, coupled with the durability concerns surrounding Max Muncy, has highlighted the need for reinforcements. Additionally, the uncertainty in the bullpen has made it imperative for the Dodgers to explore all options to maintain their competitive edge.

One of the most interesting potential additions could be the arrival of Nolan Arenado and Justin Verlander. These might initially appear to be highly unlikely trades, but there is a fair amount of reason behind such speculation.

Nolan Arenado

First of all, Nolan Arenado is a quality all-around player who put in some dazzling performances during his tenure with the Rockies. While he never managed to hit those heights at the Cardinals, a fresh start somewhere like the Dodgers makes sense. Arenado’s offensive firepower and defensive prowess would provide a significant upgrade at third base, adding another reliable bat in the middle of the order and fortifying the team’s infield defense. Plus, he would likely relish the chance to compete for yet another Gold Glove award.

The reasons against bringing Arenado to Los Angeles are multiple. First, Arenado still has four years and $76 million left on his contract. Second, it could be an unusual fit for the player amongst the Dodgers. However, the Dodgers have shown a willingness to take on large contracts and part with top prospects if it means acquiring a player who can help them win now.

Justin Verlander

Then there is Justin Verlander. He has had an interesting time with the Astros recently, and while that team doesn’t have any big selling plans, it doesn’t take too much imagination to picture Verlander making the surprise switch to the Dodgers.

Verlander’s acquisition would be particularly significant for the Dodgers. He is a proven ace with a track record of postseason success. Known for his competitive nature and ability to perform under pressure, Verlander could be the bulldog-type pitcher that gets the Dodgers over the hump in the playoffs. Pairing Verlander with Clayton Kershaw, once he returns from injury, would give the Dodgers a formidable one-two punch in their rotation, capable of shutting down any lineup in October.

Alternately

Alternately, the Dodgers could simply sit tight and hope that James Outman and Chris Taylor turn around their seasons. Betting on internal improvements, the team could also bank on staying healthy and filling holes from within. The Dodgers are already miles ahead of their rivals at the top of the National League West, even with 11 pitchers on the injury list.

Their success can be attributed to smart signings early in the season, avoiding the need for last-minute moves. The 12-year deal with Yoshinobu Yamamoto is a testament to their strategic planning, laying the groundwork for what is turning out to be a phenomenally successful season. While speculating about potential trades for stars like Verlander or Arenado is exciting, the reality is that the Dodgers may not need them. Instead, small adjustments down the stretch and faith in their current roster might just be the winning formula.