The Los Angeles Dodgers have again made headlines this MLB offseason, solidifying their position as a juggernaut in the league’s transfer market. Known for consistently pushing boundaries, the Dodgers have added key players like Blake Snell and secured fan-favorite Teoscar Hernández for another term. But it seems they aren’t done yet.
Reports are swirling that St. Louis Cardinals superstar third baseman Nolan Arenado might be the subsequent significant acquisition on the Dodgers’ radar. With a $260 million contract that stretches over several seasons, Arenado could be a game-changing addition to Los Angeles, provided the Dodgers can secure a deal.
Could Nolan Arenado’s remarkable talent and leadership be the missing piece for another Dodgers dynasty? Let’s take a closer look at this trade rumor and its implications.
Why the Dodgers Are Pursuing Arenado
Nolan Arenado is one of the best third basemen in baseball. He’s a 10-time Gold Glove winner, an All-Star, and a great hitter with 26 home runs and 93 RBIs in the 2023 season.
For a franchise like the Dodgers, adding a player of Arenado’s caliber would solidify their infield and bring even greater depth to an already formidable lineup.
The timing aligns perfectly as well. The Cardinals reportedly want to reduce their payroll and focus on their long-term goals, which could position Arenado as a desirable and cost-effective trade, especially given his impressive resume. With only a handful of teams on Arenado’s trade-approval list, the Dodgers might be his most attractive option, thanks to their championship aspirations and financial flexibility.
A Bold Trade Proposal
Jim Riley, a sports analyst, has an interesting trade idea involving the Dodgers and Cardinals.
He believes the Dodgers could trade pitcher Tony Gonsolin and utility player Chris Taylor to bring star third baseman Arenado to Los Angeles. According to Riley, the deal might also involve the Cardinals ponying up some cash. If this trade happens, it could shake up the Dodgers’ lineup. Arenado would take over at third base, Max Muncy would move to second, and Mookie Betts would play shortstop. This trade would also likely mean Gavin Lux gets traded to another team.
Although this is all just an idea for now, it shows how Arenado could fit perfectly into the Dodgers’ already talented roster.
Overcoming Salary Challenges
One of the most significant obstacles in landing Nolan Arenado is his contract. With $260 million still owed, the financial burden could give even the deep-pocketed Dodgers pause. However, for the Cardinals, shedding Arenado’s hefty salary could prove essential as they look to future-proof their team. The Dodgers, known for their willingness to invest in elite talent, may be prepared to shoulder the financial burden if it means boosting their championship hopes.
With World Series odds in mind, Los Angeles might see Arenado as the piece that keeps them competitive against powerhouses like the Braves, Yankees, and Phillies. Per FanDuel, the Dodgers currently boast a promising +320 to win the 2025 World Series, putting them ahead of teams like the Braves (+850) and Yankees (+950). Adding a superstar like Arenado could justify the financial stretch, especially if it positions them as clear favorites for another championship.
Why Arenado Fits the Dodgers’ Vision
Los Angeles isn’t shy about making aggressive moves to stay ahead in the ultra-competitive MLB landscape. Adding Arenado would bring not only statistical advantages but also an invaluable leadership presence that defines World Series-caliber teams.
Arenado’s versatility and consistency would allow the Dodgers to pair him with their current stars, creating a powerhouse infield lineup. With Mookie Betts, Freddie Freeman, and now possibly Arenado anchoring the roster, the Dodgers could once again prove why they remain perennial contenders.
Beyond the numbers, Arenado is a player who elevates both on-field performance and clubhouse culture. For the Dodgers, who prioritize building cohesive and competitive units, Arenado checks all the boxes.
High Stakes for a High Reward
Trade rumors of this magnitude are always exciting but must be taken with a generous pinch of salt. Regardless of Arenado’s remarkable talent, a deal of this size carries significant risk for the Dodgers. The brain trust will need to weigh the team’s hefty financial investment against the potential on-field gains while ensuring they don’t sacrifice too much roster depth or prospect capital in the process.
On the other hand, the Cardinals must deliberate carefully. Trading Arenado would significantly alter the dynamics of their team while opening the door for a long-term rebuild. Balancing payroll flexibility with competitive aspirations will be critical for St. Louis.
What’s Next for Dodgers Fans?
Speculation around a blockbuster trade for Nolan Arenado will continue to dominate MLB discussions. Dodgers fans can only hope their front office seizes opportunities to strengthen the roster, even if it means taking calculated risks.
One thing remains clear—the Dodgers are committed to staying at the top of the MLB hierarchy, and a player like Arenado could help them maintain their edge. With championship aspirations burning bright, this offseason could redefine the Dodgers’ path toward more historic moments.
